The Under Dog and Other Stories
Author: Agatha Christie
This collection of Agatha Christie short stories was published in the US in 1951. It was never released in the UK. Most of the stories were previously published in magazines in the US and UK from 1923-1926. So I have read and reviewed all of them previously with the exception of the title story -- The Under Dog.
These stories were all included in the 1974 Hercule Poirot story collection Poirot's Early Cases, which I reviewed in 2020 when I first started on a journey to read all of Christie's writing.
Because The Under Dog was not published in a story collection until 1951, I chose to wait to review it until later in my Christie reading journey.
Most Agatha Christie short story collections like this one mix early stories with ones published later on in Christie's writing career. It makes me do a bit of a dance trying to maintain my quest to read in publication order.
I'm not going to revisit the stories I have already reviewed. I'm including links below to my prior reviews.
Stories included in this collection are:
The Under Dog
The Plymouth Express
The Affair at the Victory Ball
The Market Basing Mystery
The Lemesurier Inheritance
The Cornish Mystery
The King of Clubs
The Submarine Plans
The Adventure of the Clapham Cook
And to round it out -- here is my review of The Under Dog. :)
The Under Dog was first published in a US magazine in April 1926, and UK publication came later that same year. Its first appearance in book format came in 1929 when it was included in Two New Crime Stories in the UK. The second story in that book was by another author, E. Phillips Oppenheim (Blackman's Wood). The Under Dog wasn't published in the UK again until the story collection The Adventure of the Christmas Pudding and a Selection of Entrees in 1960.
I do not own a physical book that includes this story, so turned to my lovely local library and Hoopla for an audio version (HarperCollins, 2012, narrated by Hugh Fraser, 2 hrs).
The basics -- Sir Reuben Astwell is dead. Not a natural death, but he died as a result of being bashed over the head. His rather ill-tempered nephew has been arrested, but Sir Reuben's wife is adamant that the nephew didn't do it. Poirot steps in to find out the truth...... and, of course, does.
I like these Novella-length stories that are too short to be a novel, but long enough to really let the plot develop. It definitely gives that Christie twistiness time to develop. Family tensions. Servant tensions. Class tensions. Who bumped the old man off? And why? 2 hours is definitely long enough for Christie to build up the tension & then have the ultimate reveal.
Great story!
Adaptations:
Poirot - Season 5, Episode 2. There are a few minor changes to the story including adding in Hastings and Miss Lemon. But, this episode sticks pretty closely to the way it was originally written. Excellent as usual!
The Underdog is the only story in this collection that is longer. The rest are shorter tales that showcase Poirot, but don't have time to really develop the characters beyond the basics. They set the stage, give details of the grisly deed, and then reveal whodunit.
Christie really was a master of marketing. Publishing these early stories in magazines built up her name and talents, so that her books sold like hotcakes.
I wish I could see just one copy of The Strand or any of the other magazines these stories originally appeared in so I could see what other stories were included, the ads, the layout -- all of it!!
Someday!!
Moving on! :) I still have so much Christie left to go!!
Next up I have Crooked House and Three Blind Mice & Other Stories.
27 novels (not counting Hercule Poirot and the Greenshore Folly as that was later re-worked into Deadman's Folly) and at least 10 more short story collections to go!! If I'm counting correctly!!






