REVIEW: Hickory Dickory Dock

 Hickory Dickory Dock
Author: Agatha Christie

Once again, this Agatha Christie novel was published in the US and the UK under different titles. It published in the UK as Hickory Dickory Dock and in the US as Hickory Dickory Death. This is the first appearance of Miss Lemon, Hercule Poirot's secretary, in one of the Poirot novels. Previously, Miss Lemon had only appeared in some of the short stories. 

My paperback copy of this book [Pocket Books, 1975, 222 pages] was in terrible shape. The spine was brittle and many pages were falling out. It was in such bad shape that it was unreadable. Every time I tried more pages dropped out. The paper was very brittle as well. So, I took photos and threw the book away. The cover art and bright orange coloring was bizarre. Gotta love those 1970s covers! 

I listened to an audio book version of this novel instead. [Blackstone Publishing, 2010, 6 hrs 3 minutes, narrated by Hugh Fraser] Hugh Fraser always does a magnificent job narrating the Hercule Poirot audio books! Once again, I thoroughly enjoyed his performance! 

The basics: Hercule Poirot notices his secretary, Miss Lemon, is upset and gets drawn into a case involving thefts at a student hostel run by Miss Lemon's sister, Mrs. Hubbard.  It soon turns into something much more serious than petty theft.  

Adaptations: 

Television: The long-running show Agatha Christie's Poirot had an episode based on this book in 1995

(Season 6, episode 2).  Lots of changes are made to the plot and time line. This isn't one of my favorite Poirot episodes. I always enjoy David Suchet as the detective, but this time the changes in the plot ruined the episode for me. 

Television: The French television series Les Petits Meurtres d'Agatha Christie made an episode based on this novel. As usual, pretty drastic changes are made including setting the story in France and replacing Poirot with French detectives. This series is fun to watch, even if it makes some pretty big changes. If your local library has Kanopy, you can watch the entire series there. Enjoy!  

I was a bit surprised that BBC Radio didn't do an audio drama presentation based on this book! I will just have to wait until I've read the next book (Dead Man's Folly) to enjoy one of their audio dramas again. They did 27 audio dramas based on the Hercule Poirot novels, so skipped six of the books. I researched online to find out why they didn't do them all. Best explanation I found was -- funding cuts.

Moving on to the next!!  19 books to go! I'm getting closer!! 

REVIEW: Destination Unknown

 Destination Unknown
Author: Agatha Christie 

I'm going to start my review by being totally honest -- 

I DNF'd (did-not-finish) this book. I've been on this journey through Agatha Christie's writing in publication order since 2020. And, I have found that I just don't like her spy thrillers. For me, the plots just didn't age well at all. 

Once again, I tried to read this. And, I found myself disliking it more and more as I went along. I got about halfway....and just said nope. Done. 

Life is too short to force myself to read something I am not enjoying. Even if it's written by Agatha Christie.  

I'm going to do a shortened review, and move on to the next book.  

This is another of Christie's books that was published under a different title in the US and UK. It was first published in the UK in 1954 as Destination Unknown. US publication as So Many Steps to Death followed in 1955. My paperback copy from 1987 [PocketBooks, 237 pages] used the original title. At one point when I was collecting Agatha Christie paperbacks I had two copies of this book because I didn't realize at the time it was the same book just published under two different titles! :) Ooops!

As usual, before being published in book format, this story was published in serial format in a UK magazine and in several US newspapers. Someday I hope I come across the magazine or newspaper versions of at least one of these novels! I'd love to see the presentation and formatting!  

My old paperback was in pretty bad shape. Yellowed pages, bent up cover that was torn at lower spine. It was time to (try to) read it and then throw it away. While I was reading and listening to the audio book, the pages started to fall out. Definitely time for it to go to that book recycling bin in the sky. :) 

I checked out the audio book on Hoopla [HarperCollins, 2012, 6 hrs 43 minutes, narrated by Emilia Fox]. I have listened to several books narrated by Emilia Fox, and she always gives a very good performance. I got about half way through and stopped reading/listening. It was not because of her narration. I just wasn't enjoying the story. 

I found no adaptations for audio or film of this book.  

As stated earlier, I lasted through half of this book and abandoned it. I didn't like the main character and the plot was just too outdated, in my opinion. I'm glad to see that others have enjoyed this story. It was just not for me. 

Moving on!  

REVIEW: A Pocket Full of Rye

A Pocket Full of Rye
Author: Agatha Christie 

Miss Marple shines in this Agatha Christie Mystery! 

This story was first published in a very condensed version in the UK's Daily Express in 1953. In the US, it ran in the Chicago Tribune in serialized format in early 1954. The book was first published in the UK in 1953, and US publication followed in 1954. 

The title comes from the well-known nursery rhyme, Sing a Song of Sixpence. I had to look up the words to the old rhyme. I hadn't heard it since we used to recite it while jumping rope on the playground when I was in grade school. As usual with nursery rhymes, it's pretty dark and gruesome. I don't think as kids we ever really thought about the meaning of the actual words. It just had a sing-song cadence that was perfect for timing jumping rope. Amazing how awful some of those old playground rhymes are as I look back as an adult. I researched a few and found that most refer back to really terrible historic events. I wonder why they got turned into children's rhymes? Odd choice! 

Sing a song of sixpence,

A pocket full of rye,

Four and twenty blackbirds

Baked in a pie.

When the pie was opened

The birds began to sing—

Wasn't that a dainty dish

To set before the king?

The king was in the counting-house

Counting out his money,

The queen was in the parlor

Eating bread and honey,

The maid was in the garden

Hanging out the clothes.

Along came a blackbird

And snipped off her nose.

I had an old paperback copy of this book on my shelves [Pocket Books, 1985, 239 pages]. The cover is bright purple...so definitely eye-catching!

As usual, I read from my paperback copy while listening to an audio book version [HarperCollins, 2013, 6 hrs 50 minutes, narrated by Richard E. Grant]. Grant did a great job of narration. At first it felt odd to have a man narrating a Miss Marple story, but as I got further into the story it made sense. First book I've listened to narrated by Richard Grant. Nice voice. He read at an even pace and did a good job of voice acting.  

The basics: A businessman is poisoned. Then two other deaths follow. The killer's biggest mistake? Killing a girl that Jane Marple cared about. Miss Marple shows up on site, angry at a disrespect shown to the dead girl, and is on the case to bring the killer to justice. 

Adaptations: 

1985 movie: A Russian movie, The Secret of the Blackbirds, is based on this book. 

Television: Miss Marple, featuring Joan Hickson as the elderly sleuth, adapted this story into an episode in 1985. Some characters were removed, and the ending was changed. I did not like the change to the ending. The end was perfect as Agatha Christie wrote it. Loved Joan Hickson as Miss Marple as usual, but found the changes to be unnecessary. 

Television: Agatha Christie's Marple, with Julia McKenzie as Miss Marple, made an episode in 2009. [Season 4, ep 1] The episode added in some sexual content that I felt unnecessary, but stuck to the original ending. I found the original ending much more profound. I'm glad they stuck with it! 

Radio play: BBC Radio 4 presented an audio drama in 1995. The audio runs 1 hr 28 minutes. June Whitfield voices Miss Marple. I love these full-cast audio dramas! June Whitfield does such a great job portraying Miss Marple. Very enjoyable listen. 

I enjoyed this story. The plot seemed a bit far-fetched in places, but it definitely kept my attention from start to finish. Not one of my favorites, but I always enjoy Miss Marple!  

My old paperback has gone into the recycle bin. Moving on to the next!!